Our Research

Image
grounds

When Julie Haizlip first learned about the concept of mattering from Isaac Prilleltensky in 2013, it immediately resonated.  She and other members of our team were steeped in a culture of clinicians and educators who were feeling the effects of working in healthcare. And while we weren’t all burnt out, we certainly understood what it meant and how it felt. (and this was pre-pandemic!)  At that time the discussion around burnout suggested that healthcare providers could minimize its effects by reconnecting with the meaning of our work.  However, our experience suggested that one could be very in touch with the meaning of one’s work and still burn out.  Meaning was necessary for job satisfaction but was perhaps not the only ingredient.  It seemed that mattering – defined as the desire to make an impact in the lives of others and to be significant in the world around you – also got to the essence of working in healthcare.

Could it be that meaning gets us into healthcare, and mattering is what makes us stay?

This question was our initial hypothesis. To investigate this question, we first sought to understand if the concept of mattering, which had previously been discussed primarily in social psychology and the educational realm, held up in healthcare and whether there was any relationship to burnout.  We performed survey studies that demonstrated that the domains of mattering as described by Rosenberg & McCullough were relevant in healthcare and that our participants who reported a higher sense of mattering also reported a lower degree of burnout.

Based on these results, we wanted to be able to characterize mattering in practicing healthcare providers and in our academic healthcare settings, and to understand the factors that contributed to clinicians, faculty, staff, and students experiencing (or not experiencing) mattering.  To explore these topics, we have conducted a series of qualitative and mixed methods studies in which we have interviewed practicing clinicians, educators, students and those who surround us.  These discussions provided rich insights into the experiences of healthcare providers and the myriad factors that contribute to both mattering and anti-mattering.

Next, we aspire to create an instrument to measure mattering specifically in healthcare environments so that we can begin to test interventions that we hope will contribute to the creation of cultures of mattering in healthcare.